I Play Rocky – a by the numbers crowd-pleaser that refuses to go the distance

I Play Rocky – a by the numbers crowd-pleaser that refuses to go the distance

The tale of the making of Rocky has become the stuff of legend, especially here in Philadelphia. We all know and love how our city’s favorite fictional hero came to be. The story of the boxer who went the distance parallels that of his creator: Sylvester Stallone. Equipped with a crooked face, drawling speech, and very little by way of a leg up in show business, Stallone took matters into his own hands, writing a script with a lead role that only he could play. With a my-way-or-the-highway attitude that defines the city of brotherly love, Stallone faced a ton of institutional resistance, and rejected a fair amount of financial persuasion. The young artist stuck to his guns and believed in himself. He would sell his script on one condition, which is also the title of this silly little feel-good movie: I Play Rocky. 

As a scholar of Stallone, Rocky, and the mythology behind it, I found it baffling which aspects of this tale didn’t make it to the screen, as well as which aspects are completely fabricated. I suspect that this has much to do with the fact that Stallone was not involved in this production, and a little to do with the fact that the IP of Rocky is no stranger to litigation. But even if this tale were a 1:1 adaptation of the facts, it would remain a disappointingly light affair. It seems the most thorough and thematically resonant adaptation of the real life tale is Rocky itself (and to a similar extent, Creed). 

I Play Rocky unfolds as a greatest hits reel from the rags-to-riches story, following Stallone (Anthony Ippolito) from his days sleeping on the streets of New York, through his early acting career where he made a meager living playing bit part thugs while tearing tickets at a local movie house. It’s there where he meets Sasha (AnnaSophia Robb), and the two begin a generally lifeless romance. 

Act two is where the film finds some energy, even if it’s undercut by the fact that we all know Stallone does indeed get to play Rocky. It’s during this central chunk that we meet producers Chartoff and Winkler (Toby Kebbell and P.J. Byrne), as well as Sandy Maddox (Tracey Letts), the Paramount exec who is adamant that Stallone not play Rocky. It makes for some fun exchanges and witty dialogue, even if it’s all just delaying the inevitable.

The third act, however, is where things get interesting, if solely for the fun of seeing behind the scenes recreations of Rocky iconography. But again, it just makes you want to watch Rocky. 

Where the film excels is in the casting and performances. Ippolito has the thankless task of recreating the image of Stallone without falling into parody, and he does a remarkable job. More than a few times I would suddenly remember that I wasn’t watching the real Stallone and be impressed with the performance anew. Same goes for Stephan James, whose Carl Weathers provides some of the film’s biggest laughs. Beyond Ippolito, the top performance goes to Jay Duplass as John G. Avildsen, the journeyman director who stepped up to the challenge of keeping an underfunded independent production on time and under-budget, lest the financiers drop the whole thing and swap Stallone out for a bankable star. 

Functionally, the movie hits all of the inspirational beats, but suffers from bad pacing and an undercooked script. Just about every plot beat results in a hanging thread. After the first day of shooting, a leg injury has Stallone waylaid. He’s told he shouldn’t be standing, let alone running. What’s a guy to do? Doesn’t matter – it never comes up again. Sasha, at one point, is revealed to be pregnant. Certainly this will cause some sort of narrative thrust. It doesn’t. It’s not even mentioned, short of a barely noticeable baby bump under Robb’s shirt. And this keeps happening. Nothing carries any weight. We just move on to the next recognizable bit of iconography. 

One choice that I found particularly strange is altering the story so that it’s the producers who decide upon the Philly setting, on account of some completely fabricated labor union fleecing. But the true, and much more interesting story is that Rocky was always a Philly-set story, and Stallone had to fight the studio to prevent it from being shot in LA and on a series of soundstages. 

Again, these choices were likely made in order to prevent litigation over the IP (Stallone did just release a solid memoir about his rise to fame and success), but even in a functional sense, these changes are merely invoked for a moment of drama and never explored in much depth. The film seems to be much more interested in recreating existing images than in telling the story behind them.

Yet despite its middling nature, it’s hard not to get wrapped up in the fanfare, especially if you’re a Philly-based Rocky fan like myself. It’s easy to turn my critical faculties off and just bathe in all the recognizable settings, marvel at the performances, and think about how cool it is that the story of Rocky came from my own backyard. Even sliced to its bare bones and left unassembled, Stallone’s story remains inspiring — a true testament to what can happen if you’re willing to do the work and follow your dreams.

Heck, you could one day have a middling biopic made about you, from the twisted minds behind Kingpin and Green Book!

Directed by Peter Farrelly

Written by Peter Gamble

Starring Anthony Ippolito, AnnaSophia Robb, Jay Duplass, Kiki Seto

Rated PG-13, 128 minutes